Dams Be Damned, Let The World's Rivers Flow Again | The Guardian

Kate Horner
Monday, January 9, 2017
Visitors gather to watch giant gushes of water released from the Xiaolangdi dam on the Yellow river in Jiyuan, China.
Visitors gather to watch giant gushes of water released from the Xiaolangdi dam on the Yellow river in Jiyuan, China.
STR/AFP/Getty Images

This article appeared as a reprint in The Guardian.

Fifty years ago, environmentalists and dam builders in the United States were locked in a bitter battle. Dam building had swept the nation in the 1940s and 1950s, blocking and impounding some of the most important rivers of the American west. On the Snake river (where controversies about dams continue to this day), dam construction had led to a massive fish kill and decimated salmon and steelhead runs.

Frank Church, a senator from the state of Idaho, originally supported the dams. But having seen the environmental damage they created, he spoke out for rivers. He saw “a groundswell of public concern for the fate of these majestic streams, many of them threatened by dams which would forever destroy their beauty and ecology”. Church authored the Wild and Scenic Rivers Act, which was passed in 1968. The Act now protects more than 12,000 miles of free-flowing rivers in the US.

For the past 60 years, large dams have had devastating impacts on people and the environment. They alter a river’s ecosystem from one that’s cold, flowing and connected, to one that’s warm, stagnant and fragmented – with devastating consequences for wildlife. Dams are one of the main reasons freshwater fish numbers are plummeting – the world has lost 80% of freshwater populations since 1970. In 2000, the World Commission on Dams found that dams were responsible for displacing between 40-80 million people.

The US is now leading the movement to decommission dams. Dam removal on the Elwha river in Washington state has been an enormous success. One year after the last dam was removed in 2014, more than 4,000 Chinook spawners were counted above the former dam site – the first time Chinook had been seen there in more than 100 years. In New York State, the Mohawks recently became the first US tribe to remove a federal dam when it took down the Hogansburg dam on the St Regis river, opening up 275 miles of stream habitat to migratory fish.

Even though the US leads the world in dam decommissioning, it continues to export a flawed development model of dam construction, and the dam-building boom has continued around the world. Not surprisingly, this has led to a groundswell of public concern about protecting free-flowing rivers.

As part of a combined effort with local communities and other NGOs, we have won enormous victories in recent months, forcing governments to cancel or suspend many destructive projects.

In April, Brazil’s environmental agency, Ibama, suspended the licensing process for the São Luiz do Tapajós dam, which was expected to be the second largest hydroelectric dam in the country, after the controversial Belo Monte power plant. In July, the World Bank suspended financial support for the Inga 3 dam on the Congo river and in the following month Endesa Chile, the country’s largest power generator, dropped six hydroelectric projects. The Chinese government has also halted plans to construct a series of dams on one of China’s last free-flowing rivers, the Nujiang. In October, the Peruvian government announced that several dams proposed for the Marañón river, a major tributary of the Amazon, are off the table during the current administration.

But after such dam projects are suspended or cancelled the rivers are, in general, not permanently protected. This leaves them at risk if a government decides to move forward with a dam in the future – giving credence to the famous quote that with the environment, victories are temporary but defeats are permanent. Water protectors must always remain vigilant, monitoring new attempts to bring back destructive dams, but we now have a window of opportunity to gain protection for critical watersheds. It’s time to turn these victories into permanent protection for free-flowing rivers.

We’re starting in Chile where Geute Conservation Sur, which defends ecosystems with high conservation value, is providing legal analysis to develop a new law for river protection in the country. And Ríos Libres (Free Rivers), a new coalition of young activists, is building public support for permanent legal river protection.

In Colombia, we’re working with Ríos Vivos to build support for protection and with lawyers to develop new approaches to long-term protection of free-flowing rivers, such as the upper Magdalena river. Furthermore, in Peru we’re reviewing opportunities to ensure permanent protection of the Marañón to secure the health of the Amazon’s headwaters.

And we cannot stop there. Transboundary rivers – such as the Nujiang/Salween river which runs through China and Myanmar, and the Gongri/Manas river in Bhutan and India – offer critical opportunities for river protection. Saving these rivers requires transboundary cooperation and when this is done right, countries can avoid the strife we’ve seen in places such as China and Thailand where conflicts have arisen over development on the Lancang/Mekong river.

In New Zealand, the government has recognised the Whanganui river by giving it the same constitutional rights as a person. This is a striking recognition that free-flowing rivers provide enormous benefits, from food security to water access, to biodiversity conservation.

It took decades of dam building – and the associated devastation of rivers – before people and their lawmakers in the US started protecting wild and free-flowing rivers. With the impacts of climate change starting to threaten livelihoods, it’s time to protect our free-flowing rivers the world over.

Kate Horner is executive director of International Rivers.

A version of this article first appeared on internationalrivers.org and has been republished with permission.

Join our community of development professionals and humanitarians. Follow @GuardianGDP on Twitter, and have your say on issues around water in development using #H2Oideas.